Page 1 of 2

opinions on the Kylin/Kirin cake at PuerhShop?

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 18:50
by zipflint
http://www.puerhshop.com/index.php?main ... cts_id=297

I'm interested in this due to the color and price. This will be part of my second order from puerhshop.com and I'm still a pu'erh n00b, so I wanted to get some educated opinions before I placed an order. I thoroughly enjoyed the previous suggestions I got here. I did a search and didn't get any results pertaining to this tea. The description sounds very intriguing!
thanks!

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 19:20
by tony shlongini
If you were to ask me to rattle off the names of some famous tea factories, Dynasty Tea Garden wouldn't be the first to come to mind.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 19:45
by PolyhymnianMuse
I agree with Tom and Tony, sheng is something you can stray away from the bigger companies more, but with shu and the way it is processed... well I just wouldn't trust some random factory. When your talking shu pu, I say stick with the factories that know how to do it and have been perfecting it since its beginning.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 19:47
by zipflint
Definitely a little pricey on a per-gram basis. That's sort of why I'm eyeballing it. I see it as an opportunity to sample some "high end" stuff, and have enough around to enjoy for a while.

:edit after subsequent replies:
ah. I did not know that this particular factory isn't one of the more established producers. I will be taking that into consideration.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 20:01
by PolyhymnianMuse
zipflint wrote:Definitely a little pricey on a per-gram basis. That's sort of why I'm eyeballing it. I see it as an opportunity to sample some "high end" stuff, and have enough around to enjoy for a while.
Please keep in mind that "high end" does not equal higher price all the time. In fact, a lot of pu heads around here are more your "bargain" shopper, looking for those really good items that arent really all that expensive.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 20:10
by engar
PolyhymnianMuse wrote:Please keep in mind that "high end" does not equal higher price all the time. In fact, a lot of pu heads around here are more your "bargain" shopper, looking for those really good items that arent really all that expensive.
Any good shu on that category?

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 20:25
by zipflint
Indeed! Been doing some more reading and have found some other items to replace this one, unless someone chimes in with a glowing review.
:lol:

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 20:50
by shogun89
In the world of Pu, high prices DO NOT mean high quality. Pick up a cake of the 2005 Tongqing, its very good and only $14 for 357g.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 21:22
by tony shlongini
You can get a reasonably priced one from Puerh Shop for under $20- the Menghai 7572.

I see they're sold out of the very nice Changtai banna tuo, but you may want to try the very nice Nanjian phoenix tuo- a whopping $2.99 for a very nice tuo of shu.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 21:49
by shogun89
tony shlongini wrote:you may want to try the very nice Nanjian phoenix tuo- a whopping $2.99 for a very nice tuo of shu.
Are these nice, I haven't tried them yet? A good price, after doing the math an qual ammount of it in a cake would cost $10.6.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 22:32
by zipflint
Thanks for the suggestions everyone. I really appreciate 'em!

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 22:44
by tony shlongini
shogun89 wrote:
tony shlongini wrote:you may want to try the very nice Nanjian phoenix tuo- a whopping $2.99 for a very nice tuo of shu.
Are these nice, I haven't tried them yet? A good price, after doing the math an qual ammount of it in a cake would cost $10.6.
They're not bad at all, and hard to beat the price. It's hard to find $3 samples, let alone a 100g tuo.

Posted: Dec 7th, '08, 23:19
by hop_goblin
If I had my choice you can't really go wrong with XiaGuan Xiao Fa or under its better known name the XiaGuan Tuocha For Export.