Wesli wrote:I eat meat. I've thought about giving it up, but have found my reasons why not to.
1) Homo sapiens sapiens (and precursor hominids) have eaten meat for their entirety of being.
I don't think this is entirely accurate. IIRC correctly, some of the early hominids had different diets that did not involve meat. Though I will not argue that energy-rich meat had a definitive part in our evolution, particularly in feeding our brains.
Wesli wrote:2) Homo sapiens sapiens seem to be the first to have fished (earliest fishing artifacts are associated with HSS), and also first to develop art, spaceships, etc. Many anthropologists believe the consumption of fish played a part in early HSS intelligence development.
I've read a few comprehensive anthropology books in the last six weeks, and I've haven't come across this idea.
Wesli wrote:3) If it weren't for our eating them, these animals would not be born in the first place.
So by my eating meat, I'm giving life. Giving life is what vegetarians and vegans think they're doing, but in reality, they're taking away the need for those animals lives.
These statements sound more than a bit anthropocentric.
Wesli wrote:Death and birth are only natural, so why not accept them as such, and use them to create a better balance.
There's nothing natural about slaughterhouses. I am all for the circle of life, but we're not talking about scavaging, or about hunter/gatherer cultures. The way meat is obtained and consumed in the US by and large is anything but natural.
Furthermore, through out history civilisations evolved as agrarian societies. We have a variety of cultivated protein sources, nuts, beans, legumes, dairy products, that may not have been readily available to our ancestors.
Perhaps vegatarians and vegans go to far, but we are a culture of consumers, and over consumption is rampant. Someone has to try and balance things.
On another note...
I think its interesting how we polarize this issue, you either eat
no meat and are a vegatarian, or you eat meat. Rather black and white.