User avatar
Mar 16th, '09, 15:49
Posts: 3
Joined: Mar 15th, '09
Location: Rochester, NY
Contact: kelvanE

Anyone else dig Silver, Snowbud, but not W. Peony ?

by kelvanE » Mar 16th, '09, 15:49

I'm wonderin' if I'm alone on this one or what. To me, White Peony and White Symphony (a refined version) taste unique onto themselves, and essentially different from the other white teas available.

I try Silver Needle and I taste the depth, subtle sweetness, and the buttery texture. I like Snowbud and its extremely light, cleansing aftertaste. I also recently received White Darjeeling and like that one a lot too--sort of a mix of the white undertone with a radiant "top" to it.

Both White Peony/Symphony were disagreeable to my palette however. I find--and not to be intentionally crass with my language here--the smell of the tea after infusion to resemble a zoo. Seriously, it reminds me of the elephant/monkey section at the zoo when I was a little kid. That weirdness carries over into the flavor as well: it tastes like a variant of the other white teas but somehow got mixed into it some strange animal essence---urine, meat, or otherwise. I dunno.

Anyone else enjoy all the whites here at Adagio except White peony and White symphony ??

User avatar
Mar 16th, '09, 16:05
Posts: 8186
Joined: Jan 8th, '08
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Southern CA
Contact: Victoria

by Victoria » Mar 16th, '09, 16:05

I'm probably the opposite; enjoying the fuller body of the White Symphony and White Peony. But I do like all of them.

User avatar
Mar 16th, '09, 22:46
Posts: 10
Joined: Jan 27th, '09
Location: MICHIGAN

by irish13 » Mar 16th, '09, 22:46

I agree with you it was just like going to the monkey cage. Only my monkey cage was with the silver needles.I had some white peach that was quite good though.

User avatar
Mar 18th, '09, 20:48
Posts: 3
Joined: Mar 15th, '09
Location: Rochester, NY
Contact: kelvanE

by kelvanE » Mar 18th, '09, 20:48

^ haha. well what the heck are the suppliers doin with the tea??

no...it's very good :)

User avatar
Mar 19th, '09, 14:37
Posts: 257
Joined: Jan 12th, '09
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: RI, USA
Contact: hooksie

by hooksie » Mar 19th, '09, 14:37

irish13 wrote:I had some white peach that was quite good though.


This I strongly agree with. :)

User avatar
Mar 19th, '09, 18:34
Posts: 6
Joined: Sep 20th, '08

by gigglestick » Mar 19th, '09, 18:34

Love Silver Needles. :D

Cannot stand Peony... in fact I threw mine away and never bought it again.

User avatar
Mar 20th, '09, 09:06
Posts: 524
Joined: Apr 10th, '08
Location: Sweden
Contact: Beidao

by Beidao » Mar 20th, '09, 09:06

I like Baimudan (White Peony) much better. I've never had any that tasted like a zoo. Drink some bad shu puerh and you will get to know what real zoo tea taste like 8)

User avatar
Mar 20th, '09, 16:06
Posts: 2067
Joined: Mar 3rd, '09

by entropyembrace » Mar 20th, '09, 16:06

My favorite white tea of the ones I've tried is the Bai Mu Dan from Jing...it has a lovely soft floral/honey character with a slight touch of astringency to balance it out...a very clean and refreshing aroma and flavour. No hints of grassiness or 'zoo'

I can't really comment on Adagio's offerings...I've been tempted to try a few but they only take credit cards. :roll:

Mar 21st, '09, 17:16
Posts: 538
Joined: Apr 1st, '08
Location: united states IL.

by silvermage2000 » Mar 21st, '09, 17:16

Well I for one like silverneedle I have to correct myself the only tea I have tried from rishi and I really like it is the ancient moonlight white.

User avatar
May 6th, '09, 14:19
Posts: 179
Joined: May 4th, '09
Location: NJ

by Rainy-Day » May 6th, '09, 14:19

It depends on particular vendor and harvest. If you don't like Pai Mutan (white peony), that's just because the one you bought wasn't good. The best Pai Mutans are absolutely incomparable. They're cheaper than SN and in theory of lower grade but when I compared the best Pai Mutans with the best SNs, it was always a wash, SNs have more buttery sweet flavour while PMs have a more balanced overall aroma and more prominent almond notes. Nominally I consider SN to be my favorite tea, but considering lower price, Pai Mutans are the best value in teas and are tied for the top spot even if you disregard the price. Of course, that's only as far as my taste is concerned :-). Oh, and if you brew a really good Pai Mutan - no zoo there, not even close.

Actually, Pai Mutans do have one flaw - even the good ones will have a somewhat rough aroma on their brewed leaves, but never from the tea itself, and never from dry leaves. It's really pretty weird and amazing - it always surpised me how this offputting aroma can be pretty strong in the wet leaves but not even the slightest shade of it is transferred to the liquor. All the good stuff is brewed out of the leaves and bad stuff only is left!

That's one refinement of SN - they're good all over, the buds that are used in SN are 100% free of that problem. It's not a big deal, though, the taste and aroma of the tea is what matters, wet leaves are thrown out anyway :-).

User avatar
May 26th, '09, 02:09
Posts: 6
Joined: May 25th, '09

by tourmaline » May 26th, '09, 02:09

I would have to say that I love Bai Mu Dan. I have been drinking it for years now, and I find its aroma and taste to be lovely, everything I'm looking for in great tea. High quality Bai Mu Dan carries within it all the sweetness of Silver Needles because a good Bai Mu Dan has a liberal scattering of downy buds ("silver needles") among the whole & broken leaf.

I have enjoyed Silver Needles many times, and while I find high quality SN (i.e. "2 Dove") to be wonderful, I still prefer the slightly more robust and rounded out quality of a good, organic Bai Mu Dan. If I find I've purchased a low quality Bai Mu Dan, I "spruce it up" by adding some SN to the leaf. To me Bai Mu Dan tastes somewhat like nutty winter squash with a little honey-butter drizzled on it. I celebrate diversity though, I love how palates differ and people react individually toward foods, films, etc.

User avatar
Jun 14th, '09, 20:05
Posts: 340
Joined: Jan 27th, '08
Location: Houston, TX
Contact: Sam.

by Sam. » Jun 14th, '09, 20:05

I really like the white peony I've tried - it's from Andao teas. http://shop.andaotea.com/products/organic-white-peony

That's the only white I've tried so I'm not sure how much more/less I'd enjoy the more expensive varieties. I'm running low on white peony (and all other types of tea) though, so I might order a sample of silver needle.

User avatar
Jun 24th, '09, 17:44
Vendor Member
Posts: 2042
Joined: Apr 4th, '06
Location: NYC
Contact: TIM

by TIM » Jun 24th, '09, 17:44

Image

This is something new to me. A 2009 white peony cake.... am I suppose to age white tea now! Just want to share. Any thoughts?

User avatar
Jun 24th, '09, 23:51
Posts: 340
Joined: Jan 27th, '08
Location: Houston, TX
Contact: Sam.

by Sam. » Jun 24th, '09, 23:51

Where'd you get a white peony cake?! Interesting.

User avatar
Jun 29th, '09, 12:04
Vendor Member
Posts: 2042
Joined: Apr 4th, '06
Location: NYC
Contact: TIM

by TIM » Jun 29th, '09, 12:04

Sam. wrote:Where'd you get a white peony cake?! Interesting.


I think this is a Taiwan/China venture Tea Company:
http://www.pinpinxiang.cn/mall/list.asp?id=551

+ Post Reply