Help with Ali Shan

Owes its flavors to oxidation levels between green & black tea.


User avatar
Aug 8th, '11, 17:50
Posts: 8186
Joined: Jan 8th, '08
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Southern CA
Contact: Victoria

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by Victoria » Aug 8th, '11, 17:50

Thanks! Nice to see you too my dear!

I'm retired now so I have less time to spend here,
ironic, huh?

Life is good. Oolong is good.

Do I sound more wise now? hahaha

User avatar
Aug 8th, '11, 18:02
Vendor Member
Posts: 2042
Joined: Apr 4th, '06
Location: NYC
Contact: TIM

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by TIM » Aug 8th, '11, 18:02

Victoria wrote:Thanks! Nice to see you too my dear!

I'm retired now so I have less time to spend here,
ironic, huh?

Life is good. Oolong is good.

Do I sound more wise now? hahaha


Welcome back Victoria. Long time : ) Great to see you here in the oolong section. Cheers ~ Toki

User avatar
Aug 8th, '11, 18:46
Posts: 2923
Joined: Oct 16th, '08
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Arlington, VA
Contact: Drax

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by Drax » Aug 8th, '11, 18:46

Victoria wrote:I'm retired now so I have less time to spend here,
ironic, huh?


It's great to see you, Victoria, and congratulations on the retirement!

And you always sounded wise...!

User avatar
Aug 8th, '11, 20:32
Posts: 8186
Joined: Jan 8th, '08
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Southern CA
Contact: Victoria

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by Victoria » Aug 8th, '11, 20:32

Aww thank you both!

User avatar
Aug 9th, '11, 07:23
Posts: 161
Joined: Aug 11th, '08
Location: Iceland

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by tsverrir » Aug 9th, '11, 07:23

You mentioned the taste being grassy. I usually find that nasty grassy taste of gaoshan means too hot water. When you start of with too hot water you've ruined the leaves so cooling the water for the second infusion is not going to help. You'll have to discard of the leaves and start over with fresh ones.

--Sverrir

User avatar
Aug 10th, '11, 00:26
Posts: 1405
Joined: Jul 21st, '10
Location: Oz

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by bagua7 » Aug 10th, '11, 00:26

Definitively! Let's sum what has been said in here so far:

1. Water being too hot

2. Infusions being too long

Let me add number three:

3. Using the incorrect brewing vessel, if in doubt a gaiwan is the safest choice.

User avatar
Aug 10th, '11, 12:30
Vendor Member
Posts: 4559
Joined: Apr 1st, '09
Location: Bangkok

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by Tead Off » Aug 10th, '11, 12:30

In my experience, gaoshan can take boiling water. I'm not sure if grassy and grainy can be the same flavor profile, just described differently. But, I have had wonderful grainy flavor from gaoshan.

Also, IME, I have been disappointed more from Alishan teas than Lishan and Shan lingxi teas. Generally, the higher the altitude, the better the teas.

User avatar
Aug 10th, '11, 12:48
Vendor Member
Posts: 2042
Joined: Apr 4th, '06
Location: NYC
Contact: TIM

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by TIM » Aug 10th, '11, 12:48

Tead Off wrote:In my experience, gaoshan can take boiling water. I'm not sure if grassy and grainy can be the same flavor profile, just described differently. But, I have had wonderful grainy flavor from gaoshan.

Also, IME, I have been disappointed more from Alishan teas than Lishan and Shan lingxi teas. Generally, the higher the altitude, the better the teas.


Also, the higher the grade or altitude (which Teadoff pointed out). The hotter water temp should be use.

User avatar
Aug 10th, '11, 13:04
Mod/Admin
Posts: 22836
Joined: Apr 22nd, '06
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Back in the TeaCave atop Mt. Fuji

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by Chip » Aug 10th, '11, 13:04

TreasureHunt Treasure 6 Clue 2 "Koudai fetish" (clue 1 was Ayu)

Tead Off wrote:In my experience, gaoshan can take boiling water. I'm not sure if grassy and grainy can be the same flavor profile, just described differently. But, I have had wonderful grainy flavor from gaoshan.

Also, IME, I have been disappointed more from Alishan teas than Lishan and Shan lingxi teas. Generally, the higher the altitude, the better the teas.

I think I agree, grainy and grassy are quite different, at least when describing green teas.

Re Ali Shan which is becoming more and more available to the mainstream, I wonder if what has already happened with Dong Ding (DD is more often used to decribe "type" versus tea actually grown on Dong Ding since supply has long been much lower than demand) is beginning to occur with Ali Shan. I have no basis for this, but we see it repeatedly in the recent history of tea. (Darjeeling too)

Or the teas are getting lower and lower in elevation ... and lower grades are more and more blended (with who knows what). Mainstream vendors selling Ali Shan will rarely have the good stuff. And if the price seems too good to be true, it probably is.

User avatar
Aug 13th, '11, 00:00
Posts: 42
Joined: Dec 25th, '10
Location: lost in 中国
Contact: garrettmc

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by garrettmc » Aug 13th, '11, 00:00

So I took you guys' recommendations for the Ali Shan. I used a higher leaf ratio to the water and even tried a great range of temperatures. However, the only thing i could get out of it was only a moderate sweetness that wasn't very impressive. Perhaps I just got a lesser quality batch or this is a bad year for this oolong. I'll probably end up trading it. thanks guys!

Aug 15th, '11, 15:55
Posts: 124
Joined: Jun 30th, '09

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by verus » Aug 15th, '11, 15:55

Let me offer some contrary advice; maybe you could try using less leaf. I know that some high end oolongs go against the usual wisdom of lots of leaf, short brews. I've had a baozhong which was undrinkable when I used a lot of leaf. Bitter and nasty. However with a moderate amount of leaf it compeltely turned around and became fantastic.

So try using a lot less leaf, and steeping a bit longer; might be worth a try before giving up on this tea.

User avatar
Aug 17th, '11, 14:07
Posts: 1112
Joined: Oct 6th, '09
Location: France
Contact: David R.

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by David R. » Aug 17th, '11, 14:07

verus wrote:Let me offer some contrary advice; maybe you could try using less leaf. I know that some high end oolongs go against the usual wisdom of lots of leaf, short brews. I've had a baozhong which was undrinkable when I used a lot of leaf. Bitter and nasty. However with a moderate amount of leaf it compeltely turned around and became fantastic.

So try using a lot less leaf, and steeping a bit longer; might be worth a try before giving up on this tea.


That's the way I use for gao shan and sometimes dong ding like oolong. Brewing longer kind of gives sweeter results for an unknown reason.

User avatar
Aug 17th, '11, 23:26
Vendor Member
Posts: 4559
Joined: Apr 1st, '09
Location: Bangkok

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by Tead Off » Aug 17th, '11, 23:26

There are many ways to brew tea. All of them are right if they suit the drinker. Gongfu style is not for everyone and every taste. But, for me, gaoshan cha is very suitable for gongfu brewing but this is assuming the tea is good quality.

The tea in question sounds like it is not a very good tea if the brewer is having so much trouble getting a decent cup out of it. I would definitely move on and try other Alishans that people recommend on this board. However, struggling with a tea can be very useful in discovering better brewing techniques.

User avatar
Aug 18th, '11, 06:49
Posts: 1112
Joined: Oct 6th, '09
Location: France
Contact: David R.

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by David R. » Aug 18th, '11, 06:49

Auhckw is selling here some Hojo's Ali Shan which I find very good if you want to try another one.

Oct 27th, '11, 03:09
Posts: 30
Joined: Oct 16th, '11
Location: Berkeley, CA
Contact: djlau

Re: Help with Ali Shan

by djlau » Oct 27th, '11, 03:09

There is a saying in Chinese: Good tea is just that, good tea. No matter how long you brew it, it will not become bitter.

It will become strong, however, but all you need to do in this case is dilute with the desired amount of hot water.

I always brew using short infusions because I want to taste the nuances, and the sweetness of the leaf.

If the tea is not high quality tea that produced with care however, it will become astringent or unpalatable when brewed too long.

+ Post Reply