From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

One of the intentionally aged teas, Pu-Erh has a loyal following.


User avatar
Aug 7th, '12, 21:29
Posts: 30
Joined: Jul 12th, '12, 21:54

From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by Charlotte_J » Aug 7th, '12, 21:29

Based on the look of this tea, do you think it is Raw or Ripe? Any reasoning appreciated. I will give details about the tea after there are some compelling answers!!

Picture of a full leaf here that teachat tells me it hates :mrgreen:

Image

Image

User avatar
Aug 7th, '12, 21:59
Posts: 402
Joined: Jul 22nd, '09, 21:54
Scrolling: fixed

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by TomVerlain » Aug 7th, '12, 21:59

ripe or shou

reason - raw tea still looks like tea leaves after twenty years - this is crumbly and black
Last edited by TomVerlain on Aug 7th, '12, 22:00, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Aug 7th, '12, 21:59
Posts: 129
Joined: Jun 19th, '10, 20:01
Location: Carlsbad, NM

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by Catfur » Aug 7th, '12, 21:59

My guess is ripe.

Aug 7th, '12, 23:37
Posts: 1280
Joined: May 9th, '09, 15:59

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by shah82 » Aug 7th, '12, 23:37

The leaves would have to be well cared for and not chopped up too much. Certainly does not look like Dayi shu.

Aug 8th, '12, 01:34
Posts: 165
Joined: Jan 4th, '12, 02:51
Location: Prague

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by JakubT » Aug 8th, '12, 01:34

Hi, have you tried rubbing it? If it is old dry stored sheng, it should not break too much. If it is shu or wet stored sheng, it should break easily.

The wet stored sheng/shu could be probably distinguished by looking for wetness of storage - the shu puerh is different really.

Also, if the tea was sheng, even wet stored, it should feel more intense on the tongue - I have yet to meet a shu puerh with good, cooling mouthfeel.

User avatar
Aug 8th, '12, 06:23
Posts: 2817
Joined: Oct 16th, '08, 21:01
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Arlington, VA
Contact: Drax

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by Drax » Aug 8th, '12, 06:23

Jakub, I think Charlotte knows what the tea is... she's just asking our opinions from the pictures.

If it is a shou, then it's possible it wasn't fully fermented, which is why the leaves still have a decent amount of integrity to them. Highly fermented shou tends to be much more scraggly than that, and you almost certainly wouldn't be able to open out a leaf like that extra picture you have without it breaking apart into bits.

If it is a sheng, then it is very old... I would guess earlier than 1980.

So that's my guess -- either younger not-fully-fermented shou, or an old sheng. That's as far as I can get from the pictures alone.

Aug 8th, '12, 08:28
Posts: 276
Joined: Jul 23rd, '09, 07:54

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by beecrofter » Aug 8th, '12, 08:28

Raw or ripe?

Yes

Aug 8th, '12, 09:33
Posts: 171
Joined: Jul 9th, '12, 16:37

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by iovetea » Aug 8th, '12, 09:33

im a complete amateur, so for me just by looking at the colour of the soup you see in the upper right corner it is sheng.....
also the leaves look more intact than usual shou..
but you can never tell, i thikn it could be both...
well i mean thats what im guessing im a complete amateur....
for me it could also be aged rock tea, or any tea.....

User avatar
Aug 8th, '12, 10:31
Vendor Member
Posts: 397
Joined: Feb 2nd, '12, 03:03
Location: RSA
Contact: SilentChaos

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by SilentChaos » Aug 8th, '12, 10:31

I'm betting shu.

User avatar
Aug 8th, '12, 14:02
Posts: 1335
Joined: May 27th, '09, 16:55

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by teaisme » Aug 8th, '12, 14:02

a Cha Tou blend, with different levels of fermentation (one in first pic looks kinda different then last few pics)

I think the nugget shapes are more a giveaway then anything that it is ripe

Aug 8th, '12, 15:44
Posts: 171
Joined: Jul 9th, '12, 16:37

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by iovetea » Aug 8th, '12, 15:44

teaisme wrote:a Cha Tou blend, with different levels of fermentation (one in first pic looks kinda different then last few pics)

I think the nugget shapes are more a giveaway then anything that it is ripe
thank you very much, you opened my eyes. yes buying pu in germany is no good idea.

User avatar
Aug 9th, '12, 22:36
Posts: 30
Joined: Jul 12th, '12, 21:54

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by Charlotte_J » Aug 9th, '12, 22:36

Ok, here is the big reveal!!

It was given to me as a sample and listed as a 1980's raw tea, stored in Hong Kong. I am not sure if that is actually what it is or not, but it tasted like wet storage for sure!! I also thought the first picture of the leaf was pretty important, as I never see shu with full leaves like that, and there were many.

Now what!? I am all ears!! :lol:

User avatar
Aug 9th, '12, 23:33
Posts: 2086
Joined: Mar 15th, '06, 17:43
Contact: MarshalN

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by MarshalN » Aug 9th, '12, 23:33

Any shots of the dry leaves?

User avatar
Aug 10th, '12, 06:25
Posts: 2817
Joined: Oct 16th, '08, 21:01
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Arlington, VA
Contact: Drax

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by Drax » Aug 10th, '12, 06:25

Charlotte_J wrote:Now what!? I am all ears!! :lol:
I guess it depends what you want to do with it? :D

If you want to get rid of (or lessen) the wet storage, you can store it in a "normal" humidity spot for a few years.

Or you can share more pictures, as MarshalN suggested. :D

User avatar
Aug 12th, '12, 03:16
Posts: 30
Joined: Jul 12th, '12, 21:54

Re: From looks alone, Is this Raw or Ripe?

by Charlotte_J » Aug 12th, '12, 03:16

Ok!! Here are the more pictures that people asked for. I still don't know whether to buy it or not - I do not mind the wet storage taste though

Just want to know what it is! I do not have anymore of the sample, it is gone now :?


editing, some trouble posting the pics on teachat--

Image

+ Post Reply