Are these seals the same?

Discussion on virtually any teaware related item.


Feb 10th, '14, 18:06
Posts: 463
Joined: Feb 3rd, '14

Are these seals the same?

by bonescwa » Feb 10th, '14, 18:06

Thanks
Attachments
$_57.JPG
$_57.JPG (23.71 KiB) Viewed 567 times
$T2eC16RHJGkE9no8hmY(BRDVv0gy4!~~60_12.JPG
$T2eC16RHJGkE9no8hmY(BRDVv0gy4!~~60_12.JPG (24.67 KiB) Viewed 568 times

User avatar
Feb 10th, '14, 20:28
Posts: 1777
Joined: Mar 22nd, '08
Location: Beijing

Re: Are these seals the same?

by chrl42 » Feb 10th, '14, 20:28

the black one is not clear, but it's clear it's not traditional one (pre-70s) :)

User avatar
Feb 11th, '14, 00:21
Posts: 2109
Joined: Mar 15th, '06
Contact: MarshalN

Re: Are these seals the same?

by MarshalN » Feb 11th, '14, 00:21

Uh, not even close. The left side are totally different

User avatar
Feb 11th, '14, 06:33
Posts: 2923
Joined: Oct 16th, '08
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Arlington, VA
Contact: Drax

Re: Are these seals the same?

by Drax » Feb 11th, '14, 06:33

Yes, you need a better picture of the top one. But, to me they look similar at the resolution available. I'd go with "inconclusive," though.

If they are the same, or aren't, does it matter? :D

Feb 11th, '14, 17:07
Posts: 463
Joined: Feb 3rd, '14

Re: Are these seals the same?

by bonescwa » Feb 11th, '14, 17:07

I was just curious, and I don't know anything about seals. I was wondering about the way that the right half of each are identical, or even information that is normally included in the seals on these mass produced types of yixing from the 90s-2000s. Obviously the maker, but I know nothing about chinese characters, but are names usually just 2-3 characters?
Thanks

User avatar
Feb 11th, '14, 19:01
Posts: 2066
Joined: Jan 11th, '07
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Re: Are these seals the same?

by wyardley » Feb 11th, '14, 19:01

In this case, it's not the maker. See threads like this for more information on some common 6 character "Meng Chen" seals used by the state-owned factories. Zhongguo Yixing is another common one (this isn't anyone's names). If these pots have any mark related to the maker at all, they'd likely be under the lid or handle.

viewtopic.php?p=191376#p191376
viewtopic.php?p=217974#p217974
viewtopic.php?p=126770#p126770 [though images are dead now]

I think what Drax was saying is that you should post a better shot of the seal on the first one if you want more information about what it says. Looks like you have them oriented correctly, and I believe it should be top to bottom, right to left. Reading seal script can be tricky, and I would definitely defer to marshaln on this subject (see some from his blog below).

Some more general information at:
http://www.marshaln.com/2008/01/monday-january-28-2008/ (also linked to in one of the posts referenced above)
viewtopic.php?f=36&t=19196

User avatar
Feb 12th, '14, 01:34
Posts: 2109
Joined: Mar 15th, '06
Contact: MarshalN

Re: Are these seals the same?

by MarshalN » Feb 12th, '14, 01:34

Both say the exact same thing, just not the same seal.

User avatar
Feb 12th, '14, 10:58
Posts: 373
Joined: Jan 5th, '14
Location: Sneeeeaking

Re: Are these seals the same?

by Fuut » Feb 12th, '14, 10:58

Maybe you should try to find a reference book that includes tokoname prefecture potters..

Seems identifying marks is a lifetime job. I found raku wares (or shino wares with thick or all-covering glazes the hardest to identify).

+ Post Reply