User avatar
Nov 15th, '08, 17:20
Posts: 747
Joined: Dec 30th, '07, 00:10
Location: Earth

Yixing vs. Gaiwan Test

by PolyhymnianMuse » Nov 15th, '08, 17:20

Since it was a pretty bleak day today being rainy and just plain miserable outside, I figured I would do a little experiment. I brewed the same tea, specialteas TKY, in my yixing pot and gaiwan to see what differences I might find. Both were measured to the same amount of leaf (5.5g) and I used the same amount of water (~4 oz.) and brewing parameters. I tried to compensate pouring times as best I could, nothing can be perfect though :P. Basically i tested the tea side by side in both the yixing and my gaiwan. Heres what happened...

Image

I didn't do a rinse, I just heated everything up and did a 30s first infusion and went from there. The aroma of the tea from the gaiwan had much more of a green quality to it in the first infusion. Color seemed to be pretty much the same. Both tasted really good but had some noticeable difference. The tea from the gaiwan seemed to have its flavors more up front and it seemed to be even a bit sweeter. The tea from my yixing however had much more of a rounded flavor and it seemed to have a much nicer mouth feel and body. It may sound funny, but the best and closest way I can explain it was that the yixing hit the flavor more toward the back of my mouth, while the gaiwan gave me flavor much more toward the tip of my tongue.

Image

I did a second 30s infusion. Each again pretty much the same color, I can only say that perhaps the tea from the gaiwan has a slightly clearer hue to it. Both had a nice nutty aroma, but the yixing tea had a very interesting different type of nuttiness that I can't explain. It seems much deeper like roasted nuts perhaps. They tasted really good again, the yixing tea was just short of a cinnamon note and again the gaiwan was a bit sweeter.

Image

The third infusion was 50s. That cinnamon note was somewhat there in the aroma of the gaiwan tea, however the flavor of that one was pretty much gone while the tea in the yixing still had some nice flavor.

Image

I quit after the fourth infusion because there seemed to be nothing left from either tea. It was quite interesting to find, although not major differences, that there was infact a taste difference that I could notice.

User avatar
Nov 15th, '08, 17:27
Posts: 3348
Joined: Feb 8th, '08, 02:10
Location: France

by olivierco » Nov 15th, '08, 17:27

Very interesting!

Thanks for sharing.

User avatar
Nov 15th, '08, 17:27
Posts: 2299
Joined: Oct 23rd, '06, 19:46
Location: Seattle Area
Contact: tenuki

by tenuki » Nov 15th, '08, 17:27

Thanks for the report and pictures!
Do something different, something different will happen. ( Gong Fu Garden )

User avatar
Nov 15th, '08, 18:17
Posts: 1051
Joined: Jul 7th, '07, 01:37
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Portland, OR
Contact: ABx

by ABx » Nov 15th, '08, 18:17

Very cool :) It's always worth trying the same tea in different brewing vessels. Some teas just seem to do better in porcelain, and others in yixing. I have some yancha that just plain won't come out right in anything but my porcelain gongfu pots, and the difference can be striking with some of the teas like bei dou (it comes out lightly floral and fruity until you get the right brewing vessel and then it comes out with a deep cherry pipe tobacco and plum base).

User avatar
Nov 15th, '08, 18:43
Posts: 5151
Joined: Dec 20th, '06, 23:33
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Gainesville, Florida
Been thanked: 1 time

by Salsero » Nov 15th, '08, 18:43

Thanks. Great experiment and wonderful write up.

User avatar
Nov 15th, '08, 18:48
Posts: 20891
Joined: Apr 22nd, '06, 20:52
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Back in the TeaCave atop Mt. Fuji
Been thanked: 2 times

by Chip » Nov 15th, '08, 18:48

A+

Thanx for sharing. :D
blah blah blah SENCHA blah blah blah!!!

User avatar
Nov 16th, '08, 02:51
Posts: 921
Joined: Feb 6th, '08, 04:57
Location: enjoying a cup of Red Rose down in GA

by omegapd » Nov 16th, '08, 02:51

Neat. So, do you have a preference now (at least with that certain tea)?

EW

User avatar
Nov 16th, '08, 05:52
Posts: 616
Joined: Mar 4th, '08, 03:53
Location: Peoria, IL

by Trioxin » Nov 16th, '08, 05:52

Interesting. Thanks for sharing your findings with us.

User avatar
Nov 16th, '08, 09:54
Posts: 727
Joined: Dec 22nd, '07, 21:02
Location: the uncharted backwaters of the unfashionable end of the western spiral arm of the galaxy

by Sydney » Nov 16th, '08, 09:54

Nicely done.

Nov 16th, '08, 12:11
Posts: 281
Joined: Feb 11th, '08, 16:49

by inspectoring » Nov 16th, '08, 12:11

Thank you....I wish I would have noticed this post prior to my other post...
A very helpful comparison...[/quote]

User avatar
Nov 16th, '08, 13:38
Posts: 39
Joined: Nov 1st, '08, 08:49
Location: Barcelona

by engar » Nov 16th, '08, 13:38

Nice experiment. Thanks for sharing.

User avatar
Nov 16th, '08, 14:50
Posts: 747
Joined: Dec 30th, '07, 00:10
Location: Earth

by PolyhymnianMuse » Nov 16th, '08, 14:50

omegapd wrote:Neat. So, do you have a preference now (at least with that certain tea)?

EW
Its funny because my preferance would probably depend on my mood, but its good to know what i can get with that tea. If i'm looking for a sweeter sharper tea I might brew that one in my gaiwan, where as I might be feeling a fuller, mellow, more nuanced (atleast the nutty flavors) I'd brew it in my yixing. I'm looking forward to trying this out with other teas side by side.

Thanks everyone for checking it out too :)

+ Post Reply