Saturday TeaDay 2/21/09 TeaScience or TeaArt?

BYOT! Enter TeaChat here, you never know what you may find!


Once again taking yesterday's topic a step further. Would you GENERALLY consider your tea preparation an art or a science. I have heard it all when it comes to tea preparation here on the forum, but are you more artist or scientist?

Definitely more of a TeaArtist
11
17%
Leaning towards TeaArtist
12
18%
Pretty middle of the road
12
18%
More of a TeaScientist
6
9%
Definitely more of a TeaScientist
7
11%
What the heck are you talking about?
11
17%
Other
7
11%
 
Total votes: 66

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 12:06
Posts: 255
Joined: Jan 12th, '09, 22:49
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: RI, USA
Contact: hooksie

by hooksie » Feb 21st, '09, 12:06

Pretty middle of the road: I tend to find a formula that works and stick with it, but not meticulously.


Loving me some Yunnan Gold this morning.

Feb 21st, '09, 12:08
Posts: 508
Joined: Apr 1st, '08, 12:43
Location: united states IL.

by silvermage2000 » Feb 21st, '09, 12:08

I guess neither I just enjoy teas.
My name i's ashley I am a female and 21 years old.

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 12:22
Posts: 20891
Joined: Apr 22nd, '06, 20:52
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Back in the TeaCave atop Mt. Fuji
Been thanked: 2 times

by Chip » Feb 21st, '09, 12:22

Chip wrote:
Woozl wrote:
esabet wrote:5) Ami I making a science out of something that is not? :)
Ah, you are trying to make a science out of an art.

-Doug- (merely an apprentice)
This is something that I have thought about for sometime, years actually. I often thought am I too precise about brewing certain tea, taking art out of the preparation, and turning into a science with test tubes, scales, and thermometers. :?:

It just kind of hit me though, a painters brush stroke can be extremely planned and precise and still be art, and he/she may be very technical in order to acheive desired results. He would not call himself a scientist, but an artist. But there are elements of both science and art in his work.

Precision does not have to equal science, it simply comes down to the preparers mind set. Despite my apparent precision, I do not consider my precise brewing an act of science. 8)
I thought of this topic some time ago and was prompted by this discussion a few days ago.

I am as always enjoying the posts by everyone. I think this topic, though it is about tea preparation, also helps us to know each other a little bit more ... and in some case confirms what we may already know. I see posters personalities surfacing.

Started the day with Yutaka Midori from O-Cha, last full session. Alas, I will not have this selection again til Shincha I am pretty sure. But there is still other YM breed leaf floating around here. I will miss this one nevertheless, as will SweeTea. Koi was very attentive and well behaved for a change. She is normally romping through the teaware disrupting the "art" that is taking place.
blah blah blah SENCHA blah blah blah!!!

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 12:41
Posts: 1289
Joined: May 10th, '08, 19:22
Location: Kentucky

by kymidwife » Feb 21st, '09, 12:41

I said "What the heck..." even though I sorta knew what you meant. :D

My personal style is very laid-back. I am totally NOT Type-A, love to go with the flow, and rarely get stressed out by details. In tea, my exception to that is brewing greens, because I have found some discipline is absolutely necessary for really good results. Otherwise, I don't usually use thermometers, measuring cups, scales, or timers. So, science, not so much. I am a guesstimator and am happy with the results I get.

Art... also not so much. I don't know beans about Chinese tea ceremony. I don't have much zen atmosphere going on. I enjoy my pretty teaware, but my tea space is not fussy and my technique is not particularly graceful.

Speaking of NOT being graceful... I just got back from the urgent care center. I took a very hard fall this morning while taking one of the dogs out to potty at my mom's... fell hard on some brick steps going up to the front door... big bump on head, a deep laceration under my chin which required 4 stitches, lots of bumps/bruises/scrapes on arms and legs... blood all over the patio... it's been quite a morning. I sincerely doubt I'll be able to get outta bed tomorrow! I am recuperating on Mom's couch, drinking sencha, and feeling thankful I didn't break my nose or knock out some teeth when my head hit that brick step.

Happy Tea Day to all... and please watch your step.

Sarah
***This organic blend is earthy & spicy, with a fragrant aroma & smooth flavor to captivate the senses. Naturally sweetened in the Kentucky sunshine & infused with natural energy. Equally delicious when served piping hot or crisply chilled.***

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 12:48
Posts: 20891
Joined: Apr 22nd, '06, 20:52
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Back in the TeaCave atop Mt. Fuji
Been thanked: 2 times

by Chip » Feb 21st, '09, 12:48

Yikes, Sarah, get better soon! :shock: :D
blah blah blah SENCHA blah blah blah!!!

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 12:51
Posts: 259
Joined: Feb 23rd, '08, 12:30
Contact: jazz88

by jazz88 » Feb 21st, '09, 12:51

@ kymidwife – so sorry to hear that! Have a rest and feel better!

I don't have time to fuss about the tea – my tea machine takes care of that.
Drinking Sencha Premier form Adagio.

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 13:10
Posts: 43
Joined: Dec 12th, '08, 03:15
Location: CA

by 10/6 » Feb 21st, '09, 13:10

I will typically use a thermometer and sometimes more if I am looking to arouse a specific character from the leaves.

If it is a tea I frequently enjoy I will usually proceed with less tools, being more used to the variables.

With that in mind, I personally believe that even art has a science, and being a musician that does a lot of work on computers I have my belief brought to attention frequently.

To be more specific... I generally use more "science" when I drink greens, and especially when I make them in the morning. :) aha. :D

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 13:11
Posts: 5151
Joined: Dec 20th, '06, 23:33
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Gainesville, Florida
Been thanked: 1 time

by Salsero » Feb 21st, '09, 13:11

Oh, Sarah, you have to take better care of yourself! Hope the recuperation is quick. You sure have had a lousy month between storms and pratfalls.

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 13:15
Posts: 43
Joined: Dec 12th, '08, 03:15
Location: CA

by 10/6 » Feb 21st, '09, 13:15

kymidwife wrote:I said "What the heck..." even though I sorta knew what you meant. :D

My personal style is very laid-back. I am totally NOT Type-A, love to go with the flow, and rarely get stressed out by details. In tea, my exception to that is brewing greens, because I have found some discipline is absolutely necessary for really good results. Otherwise, I don't usually use thermometers, measuring cups, scales, or timers. So, science, not so much. I am a guesstimator and am happy with the results I get.

Art... also not so much. I don't know beans about Chinese tea ceremony. I don't have much zen atmosphere going on. I enjoy my pretty teaware, but my tea space is not fussy and my technique is not particularly graceful.

Speaking of NOT being graceful... I just got back from the urgent care center. I took a very hard fall this morning while taking one of the dogs out to potty at my mom's... fell hard on some brick steps going up to the front door... big bump on head, a deep laceration under my chin which required 4 stitches, lots of bumps/bruises/scrapes on arms and legs... blood all over the patio... it's been quite a morning. I sincerely doubt I'll be able to get outta bed tomorrow! I am recuperating on Mom's couch, drinking sencha, and feeling thankful I didn't break my nose or knock out some teeth when my head hit that brick step.

Happy Tea Day to all... and please watch your step.

Sarah
Hmm... perhaps you are in need of a lucky charm?

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 13:32
Posts: 795
Joined: Feb 1st, '09, 20:31
Location: Columbus, Ohio

by brad4419 » Feb 21st, '09, 13:32

All science for me at the moment. I just began making loose leaf tea and still am waiting on my gaiwan to come so theres no art to my preparation now but hope to add some in the years to come.

Genmai cha today

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 13:50
Posts: 1046
Joined: Jan 15th, '08, 19:24
Location: Syracuse, NY

by Cinnamon Kitty » Feb 21st, '09, 13:50

Sarah: I hope that you feel better soon. Sencha is definitely a good pain reliever.

I am definitely more a tea artist. The idea of using a scale and measuring everything in a more scientific manner is not something that I would enjoy. I like the more artistic methods, mostly because they never result in the same cup of tea twice, but if the parameters are close enough to how I brewed the other cups of tea, the results are still tasty.

In my cup is the last of my sample of Adagio's gingerbread tea that I found in the bottom of my tea drawer. With a bit of fresh ginger root and some almond milk, it is good, but not spectacular.

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 13:51
Posts: 5151
Joined: Dec 20th, '06, 23:33
Scrolling: scrolling
Location: Gainesville, Florida
Been thanked: 1 time

by Salsero » Feb 21st, '09, 13:51

10/6 wrote: Hmm... perhaps you are in need of a lucky charm?
I fully agree. Here you go, unfortunate one:

ImageImage

You are now protected by The Force.

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 14:11
Posts: 1289
Joined: May 10th, '08, 19:22
Location: Kentucky

by kymidwife » Feb 21st, '09, 14:11

Thanks guys... and thanks Sal for the Lucky Charms... they're magically delicious. :D But on my end, they look suspiciously like ADVIL... my new best friend.

Sarah
***This organic blend is earthy & spicy, with a fragrant aroma & smooth flavor to captivate the senses. Naturally sweetened in the Kentucky sunshine & infused with natural energy. Equally delicious when served piping hot or crisply chilled.***

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 15:07
Posts: 43
Joined: Dec 12th, '08, 03:15
Location: CA

by 10/6 » Feb 21st, '09, 15:07

Salsero wrote:
10/6 wrote: Hmm... perhaps you are in need of a lucky charm?
I fully agree. Here you go, unfortunate one:

ImageImage

You are now protected by The Force.
brilliant. +1

Mitch Hedberg- "Advil has a candy coating. It’s delicious. Then it says on the bottle, do not have more than two. Then why do they have a candy coating? I cannot help myself. Let me have ten Advil, I have a sweet tooth."

User avatar
Feb 21st, '09, 15:11
Posts: 329
Joined: Jan 17th, '09, 15:45
Location: Maryland

by cherylopal » Feb 21st, '09, 15:11

(((((sarah)))))
cheryl :)

Locked